Support Partner or not?

Wed 25 March hand 17

Hand 17 is an excellent example of when NOT to support partners 1H opening.

East opens 1H and West supports bidding 2H.  East with a good hand raises or competes further to 3H.

6 out of 8 E-W pairs went 2 light. Why ?

Unfortunately for E-W trumps break 4-1 and South leads their singleton diamond.

More importantly both E-W hands are flat.  Flat hands have more losers.

If you are in NT, it doesn't matter as much if the H"s and D's break badly, but costly in a suit as E-W found out.

West should bid 1NT not 2H, the 5-3 heart fit is better in NT than in hearts, in this case.

Needless to say, the two Wests' in 1NT made 2NT.  Happy days for them.